McDowell v. Calderon, No. 96-99000 (9th Cir.) (130 F.3d 833) (November 24, 1997) (Judge Stephen S. Trott)
Loaded on Jan. 1, 1998
published in Punch and Jurists
January 12, 1998
Filed under:
Jury Instructions,
Punch And Jurists.
Case held that jury's confusion as to whether it could consider certain evidence as mitigating, in a capital sentencing proceeding, and judge's failure to adequately correct jury's misconception, resulted in an Eighth Amendment violation.
Full article and associated cases available to subscribers.
As a digital subscriber to Punch and Jurists, you can access full text and downloads for this and other premium content.
Already a subscriber? Login
More from this issue:
- U.S. v. Harris, No. 97-1812 (8th Cir.) (130 F.3d 829) (March 3, 1998) (Judge C. Arlen Beam)
- U.S. v. Harris, No. 97-1812 (8th Cir.) (130 F.3d 829) (March 3, 1998) (Judge C. Arlen Beam)
- McDowell v. Calderon, No. 96-99000 (9th Cir.) (130 F.3d 833) (November 24, 1997) (Judge Stephen S. Trott)
- U.S. v. Doyle, No. 96-1542, No. 1352 (2nd Cir.) (130 F.3d 523) (December 4, 1997) (Judge James L. Oakes)
- Stiver v. Meko, No. 96-3400 (3rd Cir.) (130 F.3d 574) (November 28, 1997) (Judge Timothy K. Lewis)
- Sealed Appellant v. Sealed Appellee, No. 97-30160 (5th Cir.) (130 F.3d 695) (December 4, 1997) (Judge Jerry E. Smith)
- U.S. v. Galicia-Delgado, No. 97-1125, No. 339 (2nd Cir.) (130 F.3d 518) (December 2, 1997) (Judge Amalya Lyle Kearse)
- Sealed Appellant v. Sealed Appellee, No. 97-30160 (5th Cir.) (130 F.3d 695) (December 4, 1997) (Judge Jerry E. Smith)
- U.S. v. Doyle, No. 96-1542, No. 1352 (2nd Cir.) (130 F.3d 523) (December 4, 1997) (Judge James L. Oakes)
- U.S. v. Turner, No. 97-1882 (8th Cir.) (130 F.3d 815) (December 5, 1997) (Judge Morris Sheppard Arnold)
- U.S. v. Noah, No. 97-1403 (1st Cir.) (130 F.3d 490) (December 2, 1997) (Judge Bruce M. Selya)
- U.S. v. Galicia-Delgado, No. 97-1125, No. 339 (2nd Cir.) (130 F.3d 518) (December 2, 1997) (Judge Amalya Lyle Kearse)
- U.S. v. Catton, No. 96-3984 (7th Cir.) (130 F.3d 805) (December 9, 1997) (Judge Richard A. Posner)
- Rowe v. Lamb, No. 96-1879 (8th Cir.) (130 F.3d 812) (November 28, 1997) (Judge C. Arlen Beam)
- U.S. v. Doyle, No. 96-1542, No. 1352 (2nd Cir.) (130 F.3d 523) (December 4, 1997) (Judge James L. Oakes)
- U.S. v. Sidhu, No. 96-50736 (5th Cir.) (130 F.3d 644) (December 3, 1997) (Judge Harold R. Jr. DeMoss)
- U.S. v. Valenzuela-Escalante, No. 96-4147 (10th Cir.) (130 F.3d 944) (December 5, 1997) (Judge William J. Jr. Holloway)
- U.S. v. Kapitzke, No. 97-1540 (8th Cir.) (130 F.3d 820) (December 9, 1997) (Judge George G. Fagg)
- U.S. v. Valenzuela-Escalante, No. 96-4147 (10th Cir.) (130 F.3d 944) (December 5, 1997) (Judge William J. Jr. Holloway)
- U.S. v. Turner, No. 97-1882 (8th Cir.) (130 F.3d 815) (December 5, 1997) (Judge Morris Sheppard Arnold)
- U.S. v. Turner, No. 97-1882 (8th Cir.) (130 F.3d 815) (December 5, 1997) (Judge Morris Sheppard Arnold)
- U.S. v. Kapitzke, No. 97-1540 (8th Cir.) (130 F.3d 820) (December 9, 1997) (Judge George G. Fagg)
- U.S. v. Kapitzke, No. 97-1540 (8th Cir.) (130 F.3d 820) (December 9, 1997) (Judge George G. Fagg)
- U.S. v. Galicia-Delgado, No. 97-1125, No. 339 (2nd Cir.) (130 F.3d 518) (December 2, 1997) (Judge Amalya Lyle Kearse)
- U.S. v. Banks, No. 96-4822 (4th Cir.) (130 F.3d 621) (December 2, 1997) (Judge Frank J. Magill)
- U.S. v. Richardson, No. 95-3053 (7th Cir.) (130 F.3d 765) (November 14, 1997) (Judge Terrence T. Evans)
- U.S. v. Valenzuela-Escalante, No. 96-4147 (10th Cir.) (130 F.3d 944) (December 5, 1997) (Judge William J. Jr. Holloway)
- U.S. v. Hinojosa-Lopez, No. 97-40183 (5th Cir.) (130 F.3d 691) (December 4, 1997) (Judge Carolyn Dineen King)
- U.S. v. Trapilo, No. 97-1011 (2nd Cir.) (130 F.3d 547) (December 5, 1997) (Judge Thomas J. Meskill)
- U.S. v. Seals, No. 96-3108 (D.C. Cir.) (130 F.3d 451) (December 5, 1997) (Judge Karen LeCraft Henderson)
More from these topics:
- Illinois Supreme Court Announces Conviction for Attempted First Degree Murder Requires ‘Intent to Kill Without Lawful Justification, Aug. 1, 2025. Jury Instructions, Ineffective Assistance of Counsel, Inconsistent.
- South Carolina Supreme Court Announces Traditional Four-Element Standard for When Person Has Right to Use Deadly Force in Self-Defense Not Applicable to Non-Deadly Force Self-Defense Analysis, May 15, 2025. Defenses, Jury Instructions.
- Minnesota Supreme Court Clarifies Standard for Determining Whether a Defendant Is Entitled to Jury Instructions on Self-defense and Defense of Others, May 15, 2025. Defenses, Jury Instructions, Jury Instructions in Jury Room.
- Maryland Supreme Court: Trial Court Abused Its Discretion by Failing to Exercise That Discretion Where It Summarily Refused Requested Jury Instruction Because It Was a Non-Pattern Instruction and ‘Some Evidence’ Supported the Instruction, March 15, 2025. Jury Instructions, Evidence - Failure to Disclose.
- Massachusetts Supreme Court Vacates Threat-Based Conviction on First Amendment Grounds Because Jury Instructions Failed to Include Mens Rea Element Mandated by Counterman for ‘True-Threat’ Conviction, Feb. 15, 2025. Jury Instructions, Resentencing, Threats, Negligence/Reckless Endangerment.
- Ohio Supreme Court Announces Self-Defense Jury Instruction Does Not Require Intent to Harm or Kill Assailant, Oct. 1, 2024. Defenses, Jury Instructions, Motive/Opportunity/Intent/Identity Evidence.
- Fourth Circuit Vacates Where Instructions Failed to Inform Jury That Mens Rea of ‘Knowingly or Intentionally’ Applies to ‘Except as Authorized’ in 21 U.S.C. § 841(a)(1), June 15, 2024. Jury Instructions, Essential Elements of Crime, Mens Rea Element, Elements of Offense, Failure to Instruct on Scienter Requirement.
- Kentucky Supreme Court Clarifies When Lesser-Included Offense Instruction Must Be Provided, Reverses Convictions Based on Trial Court’s Failure to Properly Instruct Jury, Dec. 15, 2023. Jury Instructions, Criminal Procedure, Fair Trial, Verdicts.
- California Supreme Court Vacates Second Degree Murder Conviction Where Jury Instructed on Now Invalid Felony-Murder Theory, Oct. 1, 2023. Jury Instructions, New Trial Motions, Murder/Felony Murder.
- New York Court of Appeals Announces When an Alternate Juror Is ‘Discharged’ and no Longer ‘Available for Service’, May 15, 2023. Jury Instructions, Jurors - Alternates.