Skip navigation

Punch and Jurists: November 30, 1998

Issue PDF
Volume 5, Number 48

In this issue:

  1. U.S. v. Posada-Rios, No. 94-20654 (5th Cir.) (158 F.3d 832) (October 21, 1998) (Judge Simeon T. III Lake) (p None)
  2. U.S. v. Brandon, No. 97-3812 (6th Cir.) (158 F.3d 947) (October 23, 1998) (Judge Ronald Lee Gilman) (p None)
  3. In Re City of Philadelphia Litigation, No. 96-1978 (3rd Cir.) (158 F.3d 723) (September 9, 1998) (Judge Carol Los Mansmann) (p None)
  4. White v. Fauver, No. Civ.A. No. 97-5127 (D.N.J.) (19 F.Supp.2d 305) (September 29, 1998) (Judge Stephen M. Orlofsky) (p None)
  5. White v. Fauver, No. Civ.A. No. 97-5127 (D.N.J.) (19 F.Supp.2d 305) (September 29, 1998) (Judge Stephen M. Orlofsky) (p None)
  6. U.S. v. Adkinson, No. 92-2872 (11th Cir.) (158 F.3d 1147) (October 26, 1998) (Judge James C. Hill) (p None)
  7. U.S. v. Luciano, No. 97-1221, No. 131 (2nd Cir.) (158 F.3d 655) (October 15, 1998) (Per Curiam) (p None)
  8. U.S. v. Casey, No. 97-4222 (8th Cir.) (158 F.3d 993) (October 21, 1998) (Judge C. Arlen Beam) (p None)
  9. U.S. v. Casey, No. 97-4222 (8th Cir.) (158 F.3d 993) (October 21, 1998) (Judge C. Arlen Beam) (p None)
  10. U.S. v. Salzano, No. 97-3337 (10th Cir.) (158 F.3d 1107) (October 16, 1998) (Judge David M. Ebel) (p None)
  11. U.S. v. Adkinson, No. 92-2872 (11th Cir.) (158 F.3d 1147) (October 26, 1998) (Judge James C. Hill) (p None)
  12. Garner v. Meoli, No. Civ.A. 96-1351 (E.D.Pa.) (19 F.Supp.2d 378) (August 31, 1998) (Judge Jan E. Dubois) (p None)
  13. U.S. v. Barnes, No. 96-1494, No. 223 (2nd Cir.) (158 F.3d 662) (October 21, 1998) (Judge Edward R. Korman) (p None)
  14. Knowles v. Iowa, No. 97-7597 (U.S. Supreme Court) (525 U.S. 113; 119 S.Ct. 484) (December 8, 1998) (Justice Rehnquist) (p None)

U.S. v. Posada-Rios, No. 94-20654 (5th Cir.) (158 F.3d 832) (October 21, 1998) (Judge Simeon T. III Lake)

Here the Fifth Circuit joined the holdings of the Second, Seventh and Eleventh Circuits in holding that the Reves' management and control test does not apply to a RICO conspiracy, conclusing that "Reves addressed only the extent of conduct or participation necessary to violate a substantive provision of the statute: ...

U.S. v. Brandon, No. 97-3812 (6th Cir.) (158 F.3d 947) (October 23, 1998) (Judge Ronald Lee Gilman)

Here the Court concluded that a non-dangerous pretrial detainee, whom institutional medical personnel sought to forcibly treat with antipsychotic medication solely to render him competent to stand trial, was constitutionally entitled to greater protection than that afforded by the administrative procedures delineated in 28 C.F.R. § 549.43.

The Government argued ...

In Re City of Philadelphia Litigation, No. 96-1978 (3rd Cir.) (158 F.3d 723) (September 9, 1998) (Judge Carol Los Mansmann)

Here the Court affirmed that the proper subjective standard calls for a showing of an intention to do what is known to be wrong - and based on that standard the Court did not find any legal error with the lower court's conclusion.

In one of the many cases arising ...

White v. Fauver, No. Civ.A. No. 97-5127 (D.N.J.) (19 F.Supp.2d 305) (September 29, 1998) (Judge Stephen M. Orlofsky)

In this case a class of inmates at Bayside State Correctional Facility filed a civil rights action, alleging that the guards had engaged in a pattern of physical abuse, threats and other unconstitutional acts in retaliation for the murder of a prison guard. The defendants moved to dismiss the complaint ...

White v. Fauver, No. Civ.A. No. 97-5127 (D.N.J.) (19 F.Supp.2d 305) (September 29, 1998) (Judge Stephen M. Orlofsky)

In this case a class of inmates at Bayside State Correctional Facility filed a civil rights action, alleging that the guards had engaged in a pattern of physical abuse, threats and other unconstitutional acts in retaliation for the murder of a prison guard. The defendants moved to dismiss the complaint ...

U.S. v. Adkinson, No. 92-2872 (11th Cir.) (158 F.3d 1147) (October 26, 1998) (Judge James C. Hill)

United States v. Adkinson, 135 F.3d 1363 (11th Cir. 1998) (Judge Hill) ("Adkinson I")
United States v. Adkinson, 158 F.3d 1147 (11th Cir. 1998) (Judge Hill) ("Adkinson II")

These two rather extraordinary decisions deal principally with a Klein tax conspiracy and they are noted because they show the extremes to ...

U.S. v. Luciano, No. 97-1221, No. 131 (2nd Cir.) (158 F.3d 655) (October 15, 1998) (Per Curiam)

Last year the Second Circuit authoritatively pronounced: "We have never held that a failure to pay fees or an attorney's motion to withdraw for his clients failure to pay, without more, gives rise to a conflict of interest and decline to do so here." U.S. v. O'Neil, 118 F.3d 65, ...

U.S. v. Casey, No. 97-4222 (8th Cir.) (158 F.3d 993) (October 21, 1998) (Judge C. Arlen Beam)

The defendant in this case was charged with bank theft, counterfeiting and access device fraud. He ultimately pled guilty, although there was no written plea agreement. He was sentenced under the Guideline applicable to burglary - and on appeal he argued that he should have been sentenced under the Guideline ...

U.S. v. Casey, No. 97-4222 (8th Cir.) (158 F.3d 993) (October 21, 1998) (Judge C. Arlen Beam)

In this case the Court explored the meaning of "atypical case" as used in USSG § 1B1.2(a) and, while it held that this was not an "atypical case", it also held that the district court erred by applying the proviso.

The defendant in this case was charged with bank theft, ...

U.S. v. Salzano, No. 97-3337 (10th Cir.) (158 F.3d 1107) (October 16, 1998) (Judge David M. Ebel)

Here the en banc court essentially affirmed, over Judge Bright's dissent, a prior panel's decision that holding the defendant in detention until canine dogs arrived was unreasonable and not supported by sufficent probable cause.

United States v. Salzano, 149 F.3d 1238 (10th Cir. 1998) (Judge Ebel)
United States v. Salzano, ...

U.S. v. Adkinson, No. 92-2872 (11th Cir.) (158 F.3d 1147) (October 26, 1998) (Judge James C. Hill)

QUOTE OF THE WEEK - Some observations on the elastic, sprawling, pervasive offense of conspiracy.

"This case [the Krulewitch case] illustrates a present drift in the federal law of conspiracy which warrants some further comment because it is characteristic of the long evolution of that elastic, sprawling and pervasive offense. ...

Garner v. Meoli, No. Civ.A. 96-1351 (E.D.Pa.) (19 F.Supp.2d 378) (August 31, 1998) (Judge Jan E. Dubois)

This is a rare case in which the Court refused to vacate a jury award of punitive damages, in the amounts of $500,000 and $250,000, against two police officers for using excessive force during a warrantless search of plaintiffs' home.

U.S. v. Barnes, No. 96-1494, No. 223 (2nd Cir.) (158 F.3d 662) (October 21, 1998) (Judge Edward R. Korman)

In this case, the defendant was convicted of conspiracies to distribute, inter alia, heroin and crack. Although the district court arrived at a Guidelines sentencing range lower than the 20-year minimum sentence applicable to a conspiracy involving crack, it imposed the 20-year minimum. However, the statutory minimum sentence applicable to ...

Knowles v. Iowa, No. 97-7597 (U.S. Supreme Court) (525 U.S. 113; 119 S.Ct. 484) (December 8, 1998) (Justice Rehnquist)

Here the Court held that a warrantless search of a vehicle whose driver has been cited for but not arrested for a traffic offense may not be sustained on the basis of a "search incident to citation" theory.

Essentially, in this case, the Court ruled that the rationales underlying the ...