Smith v. Cain, No. 10-8145 (U.S. Supreme Court) (565 U.S. 73; 132 S.Ct. 627) (January 10, 2012) (Justice (John G.) Roberts)
Loaded on Jan. 23, 2012
published in Punch and Jurists
January 23, 2012
Filed under:
Punch And Jurists,
Withholding of Exculpatory Evidence.
Here the Court reversed a murder conviction because the New Orleans prosecutors withheld materal exclupatory evidence; but the decision is noted for Justice Thomas' astonishing dissent in which he recreated the evidence to reach a different result.
In this case, the Supreme Court reversed a first degree murder …
Full article and associated cases available to subscribers.
As a digital subscriber to Punch and Jurists, you can access full text and downloads for this and other premium content.
Already a subscriber? Login
More from this issue:
- In Re NSA Telecommunications Records Litigation, No. 09-17133 (9th Cir.) (669 F.3d 928) (December 29, 2011) (Judge M. Margaret McKeown)
- Minneci v. Pollard, No. 10-1104 (U.S. Supreme Court) (565 U.S. 118; 132 S.Ct. 617) (January 10, 2012) (Justice Breyer)
- Perry v. New Hampshire, No. 10-8974 (U.S. Supreme Court) (565 U.S. 228; 132 S.Ct. 176) (January 11, 2012) (Justice Ginsburg)
- Maples v. Thomas, No. 10-63 (U.S. Supreme Court) (565 U.S. 266; 132 S.Ct. 912) (January 18, 2012) (Justice Ginsburg)
- Gonzalez v, Thaler, No. 10-895 (U.S. Supreme Court) (565 U.S. 134; 132 S.Ct. 641) (January 10, 2012) (Justice Sotomayor)
- Smith v. Cain, No. 10-8145 (U.S. Supreme Court) (565 U.S. 73; 132 S.Ct. 627) (January 10, 2012) (Justice (John G.) Roberts)
- Jewel v. National Security Agency, No. 10-15616 (9th Cir.) (673 F.3d 902) (December 29, 2011) (Judge M. Margaret McKeown)
- In Re: National Security Agency Telecommunications Records Litigation, No. 09-16676 (9th Cir.) (671 F.3d 881) (December 29, 2011) (Judge M. Margaret McKeown)
More from these topics:
- Chicago Pays Exonerated Prisoners $7.5 Million, Bringing Total to $33.75 Million for Wrongful Convictions, Jan. 1, 2026. Wrongful Conviction, Bribery/Extortion/Theft, Fabrication of Evidence, Withholding of Exculpatory Evidence, Withdrawal.
- Enormous $14 Million Settlement Reached by Los Angeles County with Former Prisoner Exonerated After 20 Years, Nov. 1, 2025. Municipal Liability, Fabrication of Evidence, Favorable Disposition, Eyewitness Identification, Withholding of Exculpatory Evidence.
- SCOTUS Overturns Oklahoma Prisoner’s Death Sentence After More than 25 Years on Death Row, Nov. 1, 2025. Ex Post Facto, Good Time, Wrongful Conviction, Habeas Corpus, Wrongful Imprisonment, Pardons/Clemency, First Step Act, Civil Asset Forfeiture Reform Act (CAFRA), Specific Offenses, Controlled Substances, Weapons, Accuracy of Information, Depraved Indifference Murder, Evidence - Circumstantial, Theft, Failure to Disclose, Perjury/Perjured Testimony, Evidence - Failure to Disclose, New Trial - Motions for, Pleas Linked to Cooperation, Evidence - Destruction/Fabrication/Manipulation of, Selective Prosecution/Enforcement, Improper Comments, Official Report, Withholding of Exculpatory Evidence, Exculpatory Evidence - Disclosure Obligations.
- NYC Murder Convictions Vacated After Withheld Evidence Reveals “Factually Impossible” Coerced Confession, Oct. 15, 2025. Forensic Sciences, Police Interrogations, Coercive Interrogations, Confessions - Coerced, Withholding of Exculpatory Evidence.
- Louisiana Supreme Court Springs Prisoner From Death Row, April 1, 2024. Capital Punishment, Exculpatory Materials, Perjury/Perjured Testimony, Evidence - Failure to Disclose, Withholding of Exculpatory Evidence.
- D.C. Circuit Orders New Trial Due to Brady Violations Involving Source of Information, Not Withholding of Information Itself, Oct. 1, 2023. Brady Violations, Withholding of Exculpatory Evidence.
- Hawaii Supreme Court: Due Process Violation to Exclude Evidence of Victim’s BAC in Assault Case in Which Defendant Claims Self-Defense, May 1, 2022. Assault Weapons, Withholding of Exculpatory Evidence.
- Eighth Circuit Affirms Habeas Relief Decades After Conviction Because Prosecutor Destroyed Evidence Prior to Trial, July 15, 2020. Habeas Corpus, Withholding of Exculpatory Evidence.
- Federal Court Grants Default Summary Judgment in Favor of Indiana Prisoner as Sanction for State’s Lies, May 1, 2020. Excessive Force, False Statements/Perjury, Withholding of Exculpatory Evidence.
- Mattox v. U.S., No. 667 (U.S. Supreme Court) (156 U.S. 237; 15 S.Ct. 337) (February 4, 1995) (Justice Brown), March 27, 2019. Punch And Jurists, Confrontation Clause/Rights.